Santa Cruz: Why I Hate You

Or How the Recall Broke My Spirit

Santa Cruz was once a forgotten beach town, a little ratty around the edges, but charming and scrappy too.

There are many times in my 35 years in Santa Cruz that I considered leaving town. The recent recall effort might be the low point for me. I can barely bring myself to read the news or check in on Facebook. The sheer chutzpah of the naked and obvious lies that a conservative coalition is willing to spread in order to sink the two most progressive city council members on the first progressive majority Council in a decade is shocking.

George W. Bush’s chief strategist Karl Rove, who’s mentor was Nixon’s dirty tricks guy Donald Segretti, used to say, We’re not looking at the next election, we’re making plans for a Republican century. This includes taking control of local electoral politics that the Dmeocrats had long ceded.

It’s shocking, but it shouldn’t be. For two reasons: What we are seeing in local politics is part of a national conservative trend to dominate electoral politics from the highest office right down to the school and water boards. And the dirty tricks we are seeing locally are nothing new. They were being used by Donald Segretti in the ’70, his mentee Karl Rove in the W years, and by Trump and his cronies today. They win at the margins, by sowing doubt and shaving off tenths of percentages.

The second reason is that Santa Cruz has never been what it advertised.

The recall is not an anomaly for Santa Cruz. It is part and parcel of a town that likes to sell itself as a liberal paradise, but is actually at heart conservative, whose white majority are racist, anti-homeless, and pitted against the poor. It’s only stupid saps like me who are naïve enough to believe in some core goodness who are aggrieved by current local politics. (Perhaps I should take my own advice as it applies to the rising wave of fascist conservative politics: Don’t watch their mouths, watch their hands.)

What Is Art? was a tiny, 50-person-capacity venue run by a collective of people from the Santa Cruz art and music scene. It ran out of a North Pacific storefront from the mid-90’s until 2000.

Almost everyone I know has been priced out of Santa Cruz. All the artist and artist collectives and groups working out of cool warehouse spaces in the 90s and early oughts are gone. All of the businesses that made Santa Cruz unique and interesting are slowly falling one by one leaving a bleak hellscape of corporate chain stores.

Once Santa Cruz was a forgotten beach community, a little rundown, but also charming in a kind of funky and weird way. There was a university up on the hill and some town-gown tension, but also a cosmopolitan hippy influence with the Agro-ecology program, the Alan Chadwick garden, the Community Studies major, Feminist Studies, ex-Panther Angela Davis, and the Whole Earth vegetarian restaurant. There was occasional tension and conflict, but it was small town, the kind of thing that works out with time.

Santa Cruz Pacific Garden Mall after the 1989 Loma Prieta Earthquake. After the quake, Pacific Ave was definitely a mall, but the “garden” got dropped somewhere along the way.

The 1989 earthquake, which devastated downtown and killed three, was a tragedy for some and a heyday for opportunistic developers. They saw Santa Cruz as an Undiscovered Territory and an opportunity to bring in investment capital. With a growing university on the hill and a growing tech industry in the valley, rebuilding Santa Cruz from the ground up on the pattern of Los Gatos was a sure win. A liberal paradise, a funky but successful laid-back beach community, this was how we would sell it. But money, no matter what it says, is always conservative. And that post quake Downtown Association set the course.

After the quake, it was the local business community, in their desperation to compete with (of all things) Capitola Mall, that engineered the homogenization to which they are now falling prey. “Straighten the street!“ they cried. “Put in more parking! Make it more car friendly! Make it easier to get in and get out like a mall!” In the 90s downtown businesses wanted more chains, “anchor stores“ that would draw people downtown. And when that didn’t bring people down to buy their overpriced tchotchkes, the town which sold out for a greasy buck needed a scapegoat.

In the early 1980’s, a series of explosive scandals rocked the police department as officers were found to routinely assault transients. “It was a lot of fun,” said one SCPD officer.

For the next twenty years, we heard anti-homeless rhetoric ratcheting up. “Aggressive panhandlers,” we read every week with quotes by little old ladies, “I’m scared to come downtown.“ Now conservative local leaders seriously propose putting them in camps elsewhere in the county. In more private forums, people openly propose bringing back “Code Blue,” the scandalous period in the 80s when SCPD officers were discovered to be using the radio call as a code to go “trollbusting,” ganging up to physically assault homeless people.

During the recall effort (which, depending on which supporter you ask, is principally about the recall targets’ support of rent control, support of homeless people, or workplace behavior) incidents of anti-homeless and white supremacist activity have increased.

Santa Cruz can be proud to be pioneers of a host of rising national trends: the blanket ban, the sleeping ban, the sitting ban, the loitering ban, time limits on park benches, smoking bans in the park then elsewhere. A ban on dogs, a ban on hacky sacks, frisbees, and bubbles. A ban on chalking the sidewalk. Severe limits on sidewalk vendors. severe limits on public speech. Draconian parking enforcement so that you got a ticket every other time you came downtown. Severe limits on street musicians. increased enforcement then even more increased enforcement. Outsized police department spending and a police force size twice that of towns our size.

Despite the author’s pessimism, there are still some funky places hanging on by their fingernails in Santa Cruz. SubRosa Community Space holds down a rapidly gentrifying part of Pacific Ave. in a courtyard shared by The Fábrica, Bike Church, and PedEx.

The irony is that despite the efforts of those post-quake planners, Santa Cruz sold its soul. Money is killing this town. Or at least everything that makes it unique, special, and authentic. Naturally, new arrivals in town will find it charming in a generic sort of way, and new people will bring new blood and create interesting experience. And to be sure, there will still be money made off of Santa Cruz, but it will increasingly travel out of town to the shareholders of corporate chains. This is the trajectory of capitalism. Capital gathers capital.

I’m lucky enough to live up in the hills. I don’t come down to Santa Cruz unless I have to and then I make it brief. Even then I am consistently shocked by what has been lost. Et tu, Pergolessi? But still Santa Cruz bumps up against my Facebook feed and I want to leave and never come back. Instead, I look at the trees and the sky out here in the mountains and enjoy the sun on my face and try to forget the poisonous politics just down the road.

So what of those who are still stubborn, naïve, or stupid enough to resist? As has been happening for the last 30 years, they will eventually be forced out in one way or another. When we go, we will leave to you a charming little beach town, squeezed of all its character, uniqueness, and authenticity.

Postscript: In 2025, after 37 years in Santa Cruz County, I left for a professorship in Cincinnati, Ohio.

Originally published on Medium, October 20, 2019.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *